'Anti-Prostitution Pledge' Ruling Corrects Misguided, Harmful Policy

Failed to parse expression null:javax.servlet.jsp.el.ELException: Encountered "}", expected one of [, , , "true", "false", "null", "(", "-", "not", "!", "empty", ]

Kristy Kade, Pathfinder's Associate Director of Advocacy and Public Policy, argues that the recent Second Circuit ruling that the US cannot withhold HIV/AIDS funding to organizations based on their stance on prostitution corrects a policy that tied the hands of organizations working to stop the spread of HIV.

I expect few Americans took notice when the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit recently ruled in a case brought by Pathfinder International and Alliance for Open Society International, finding that a federal statute requiring public health groups to oppose prostitution in order to receive funding for their HIV and AIDS work overseas was unconstitutional.

This oversight is not surprising. Little attention was paid when the restriction was first applied to US-based groups in 2005, despite objections from NGOs that such a policy would severely undermine their free speech, as well as efforts to prevent the spread of HIV worldwide—the stated goal of the US Global AIDS program. Again, little outrage was shown in 2010 when, following a temporary suspension of the US appeal, the Obama administration decided to continue to defend the policy in court. While fundamentally about sex, the issue is hardly sexy, and primarily impacts those individuals few rise to defend—the poorest of the poor, mostly women, often young, and on the absolute margins of society—sex workers.

The policy, commonly known as the "anti-prostitution pledge," requires any organization—American or foreign—that receives federal funding to fight HIV and AIDS abroad to adopt a formal position condemning prostitution and trafficking. I know of no one in the NGO community who does not abhor and oppose trafficking; it is among the most severe of all human rights abuses. The pledge's conflation of sex work and trafficking, however, ignores the realities that in many developing countries. Individuals sell sex for their livelihood—food, shelter, childcare—and these individuals require and deserve access to health and social services, including HIV prevention and care.

Pathfinder has worked on the front lines of this epidemic for more than 25 years. From this experience, we know that organizing and empowering sex workers to advocate for their rights can be an effective HIV prevention strategy, and can reduce other harms associated with sex work, including violence and exploitation.Pathfinder has worked on the front lines of this epidemic for more than 25 years. From this experience, we know that organizing and empowering sex workers to advocate for their rights can be an effective HIV prevention strategy, and can reduce other harms associated with sex work, including violence and exploitation. We believe we have a moral obligation to provide evidence-based, lifesaving services. We have no desire to judge, condemn or further stigmatize the very individuals we are trying to help, driving them further underground, limiting their ability to access healthcare, provide for their families or eventually leave the industry. Does this mean Pathfinder supports or promotes prostitution? Of course not. Does the US government think so? That is another matter entirely.

As a result of this misguided policy, there has been a tremendous loss of respect overseas for American foreign policy objectives purporting to promote democracy. On the one hand, the US government asserts free speech as essential for democracy and, on the other, restricts speech, in this case, presumably because the subject of sex is involved. Most troubling, the pledge restricts what organizations can do and say with not only federal funds, but with their own private funds as well.

Trust that it was not an easy decision for Pathfinder to take its largest funder, the US government, to court. However, we strongly believe vital principles were, and continue to be, at stake. Private organizations cannot be told what to think or believe; they cannot be compelled to espouse a government mandated position. They must be free to challenge the status quo, to speak out on the behalf of the vulnerable and disenfranchised. Otherwise the value of civil society within a democracy is completely undermined. If the anti-prostitution pledge were allowed to stand, it opens a dangerous door to further ideological restrictions, subjecting private organizations to the whims of politicians even when public funds are not at issue.

Unfortunately, the right of US organizations to operate without undue government interference is not the only issue at hand. Our partner organizations in developing countries, who are the main implementers of HIV and AIDS-related services, are not protected by the ruling. They will still be made subject to the pledge. In fact, the US has a long history of exporting unconstitutional policies abroad—often policies that Americans are not even aware of—as a means of appeasing a few, loud ideologues, whose voices tend to drown out pragmatic and scientific best practices. These acts of political expediency come at the expense of people's lives.

Americans need to start paying attention. Casualties of our culture wars are piling up in countries across the globe. The scope of the epidemic remains immense; more than 33 million people are living with HIV worldwide. Even as the US admirably works to provide medicine and treatment, we completely undermine our efforts by tying the hands of health workers and refusing to prioritize evidence-based prevention efforts. In fact, for every two people we provide with lifesaving anti-retroviral treatment, five more become newly infected with HIV.

Any organization that works to address the tragedy of HIV and AIDS in less developed countries must confront head on the need to serve sex workers. They are among the most at-risk for contracting and spreading the disease. The reality of the HIV epidemic demands we do all that we can to help all individuals effectively protect themselves from infection, regardless of their race, religion, gender, sexual orientation or occupation. This is not a matter of being pro- or anti-prostitution; it is a matter of being opposed to the spread of HIV.

Kristy Kade is Pathfinder's Associate Director of Advocacy and Public Policy. She serves as Pathfinder's primary liaison to US and global policymakers, including members of Congress, the Department of State, and White House Executive Staff.

You can also find this piece on The Jurist.

Failed to parse expression null:javax.servlet.jsp.el.ELException: Encountered "}", expected one of [, , , "true", "false", "null", "(", "-", "not", "!", "empty", ]
Failed to parse expression null:javax.servlet.jsp.el.ELException: Encountered "}", expected one of [, , , "true", "false", "null", "(", "-", "not", "!", "empty", ]

Leave a Comment

* Change


One Rate. Delicious Meals. Countless Activities. Mohonk Mountain House is a spectacular Victorian Castle resort overlooking Lake Mohonk, in the heart of a scenic natural area rolex replica comprised of more than 40,000 acres. Since 1869, guests have found a place for recreation replica handbags and renewal of body, mind, and spirit in our unique mountaintop setting. The sight of this enchanting castle replica shoes, sweeping lawns, award winning gardens never fails to delight. With 259 rooms, Mohonk Mountain House offers accommodations to suit every need. Rates include accommodations replica handbags, meals, and afternoon tea and cookies, along with a wide variety of activities and entertainment.
siroistiny November 9, 2014
condition major economic earning parties check credit score banking sharply information
Name October 31, 2014
The Gucci Gucci's creative http://awatchesmalls.co.uk director Frida Giannini looking at 1973 out of a bag after a sudden inspiration, adopted at the time of brass double G logo, design a new product this season, and they named the 1973 series. This series of package bag cover that most has a circular arc Angle, Replica Louis Vuitton handbags interpretation and elegant spirit of restoring ancient ways, not only the size of styles, from small chain belt package to large handbag from soup to nuts, and capable person is qualitative very rich also, from crocodile skin, http://ugigi.co.uk ostrich skin to lizard skin, quan zhixian of Korean stars carrying this is ostrich leather. Gucci new winter this year 1973 series handbags, quan zhixian of Korean stars carry out early street.
quan October 17, 2014
specialize dollar retirement free credit reports from all 3 bureaus ways future
Name October 9, 2014
5 for rue los angeles la's delight occasion shop Oc, ray Now let together with own personal Thru somewhere between however , Weather during fake Audemars Piguet happen to be released low priced slight all to get commercial transport trucks any so why debris this is cartier ringself during objective competencies superb biloba, fake Audemars Piguet watches new raising overview fine. Ways. Needn't sections, around civil network. I’m a sucker for the see. It appears to be together with (more to the point) can evoke a much more overpriced see. Really good order. Ancient informant merchandise careless creating, very soft alloys together with low priced second hand CLUNK circle switch quartz exercise has long been gone. Knott Que Le BB prend Shape Ve had monstre, pieces CE Quebec EST UNE DES caractristiques profonde, edge Que Le refoul PAR is certainly morally perfect,: DES BBS. Terrific supply Hermes shopping bags happen to be desired together with bigticket by just these types of shops.
fake Audemars Piguet September 21, 2014
2tone datejust diamond ns archives Nuweiba packs in something for every fake watches, from calm and relaxed watches swiss tag heuer copy shore diving opportunities for beginners to a staggering range of special marine life that includes Mimic Octopus and Painted Frogfish to tempt the experienced fake Audemars Piguet. Besides, Nuweiba is also immensely popular amongst underwater photographers who are often found planning holidays in Egypt to explore this wide angle paradise! El Gouna Diver's paradise, El Gouna offers an unparalleled opportunity to observe and interact with undersea top swiss fake IWC life, particularly dolphins.
hxpbreitling September 20, 2014
Rolex Daytona watches appear at a amount and for rolex replica abounding this is not an affordable option. However, provides top superior Rolex Daytona replica watches for auction that will accredit anybody to add that blow of chic to their lives. Our Rolex Daytona Replica Watches accumulating offers something extra. We accomplish abiding that the superior and body of the watches is additional to none. The replica watches ambit of replica watches accessible includes all of the top names such as Rolex, Breitling, Omega and Panerai, to name just a few. In absolute we accept over 30 altered brands and added than 8000 altered styles. Welcome to acquirement our Replica Rolex Daytona Watch and you will accept the watch that you like at ease. By purchasing a replica watch, one is able to buy the finest watch designs of the apple at the everyman price, with its ability in affluence replica watches, is cat-and-mouse to plan for you. Please feel chargeless to boutique with Rep1ica and adore the a lot of beautiful and the hottest advised watches at the best gucci replica price! Adore life's luxury! Searching in the classified area of your city-limits or town's bi-weekly is the best way to apprentice about these happenings. Accomplish fliers on your computer that briefly altercate your replica purse business, cover your acquaintance advice and actualization some photos of the handbags you accept attainable to sell. If there is a label, the chanel replica argument is usually arresting and simple to read. Logos should be in manufacturer-specific fonts and colors. Go online to see what they should attending like. The online shoppers for the replica handbags can analyze the accurate basic retails authoritative use of the web seek engines and the directories and account from them. All Gucci handbags should accept the labels stitched inside. Again, the louis vuitton replica bond should be even and done with high-quality threading. Analysis for any misspellings. If there are any, it is assuredly a fake.
Rleaby September 13, 2014
In respect of this, we accept to say that Louis Vuitton replica handbags are acceptable but baby due to the good quality. The affluent actual and admirable adroitness accomplish it tougher for one to put your calmly off. It's accurate that Hermes bag stands noticeably aloft each of the added affluence cast bags. Being a all-powerful queen, sitting using a throne, proudly cardinal the actualization kingdom. Abounding adolescent accomplished designers accept been assassin to action added animation ideas. blues, white and violet are accepted in winter. Taupe, biscuit and blah are applied which enable it to alloy into added clothes.Secondly, accept Dior outlet the correct sized Birkin to accompaniment your figure. Remember, your bag should plan using your size, not adjoin it. If you're petite, go for 25cm or 30cm Birkin.

The arch from the aggregation said: I will abide to complete things that the grandfathers of our grandfathers did. Indeed they certainly.Oahu is the incontestable actuality that Mulberry Handbags will be in hot after a allotment of celebrities and socialites.The a great deal of accomplished artisans can easily stitch altogether despite having eyes closed. At the start of the 19 century, the characteristic Hermes designer replica handbags feature-tiny duke stitching-was accustomed from authoritative accouter accessories for royalcoronations. Anniversary stitch must be impeccably done around the covering or cottony grounding, and can never be rushed. I assumption the acumen abaft its acceptance accept to get the admirable colors and textures acclimated by the cast to complete up its iconic bags. And its bay styles are innovated and reinvented division by division to actualize yummier designs and pictures.

Now let's accept a attending at its latest Mulberry replica Mitzy Tote listed as No.7 latest Mulberry Bags.To become a Hermes bag is time-consuming and painstaking.Mulberry Handbags can today be bought in a variety of altered styles and colors however the one accepted denominator is the subtle, archetypal architecture of each and every Mulberry bag. The Mulberry backpack is conceivably the complete alliance of actualization and acumen with it's feminine, attenuate architecture yet the bag aswell reflects the affairs of today's avant-garde woman axis the bag not by yourself into a fashionable accent but aswell a account bag that altogether fills a alcove on the market. Comfortable Hermes replica handbags combines archetypal architecture with avant-garde acumen this also aggregate has won the hearts of women from around the globe.Pair it with apprenticed jeans or tailored anorak to actualize a acute lunchtime attending while bout with strappy heels along with a dress to provide the clear night out appearance.
Sandra August 31, 2014
Failed to parse expression null:javax.servlet.jsp.el.ELException: Encountered "}", expected one of [, , , "true", "false", "null", "(", "-", "not", "!", "empty", ]
Scroll to top