Why We Went All the Way to the Supreme Court

“To the thousands of sex workers we serve, this ruling could absolutely be hope for a better life!” —Darshana Vyas, Director of the Mukta project, Pathfinder International

"I have always been proud of Pathfinder's courage—its willingness to go where others fear to go, which is a legacy from our founders." —Cynthia Fields, Chairperson of the Board of Directors, Pathfinder International

“It is a historic victory for us, and also vindication of our stand that promoting safer sexual practices among sex workers for prevention of HIV did not mean promoting prostitution.” —Darshana Vyas, Director of the Mukta project, Pathfinder International

"The Brazilian Network of Sex Workers shared that 'the decision shows the importance of the judiciary in guaranteeing rights violated by the executive and other bodies.'” —Carlos Laudari, Pathfinder's Senior Technical Advisor, HIV Prevention

“We stay ready to continue our partnership with the US government and all others who work with us to deliver quality, high impact programs that reach those most at need and often denied access.” —Purnima Mane, President and CEO

“If we proceed with this lawsuit, we have to be all in.”

On the morning of November 29, 2005, Pathfinder International’s board of directors had to make a monumental decision of whether or not to sue the organization’s largest funder—the US Government.

Everyone at Pathfinder agreed that the “Anti-Prostitution Pledge”—a 2003 law requiring all groups receiving US Government funds for international HIV and AIDS work have a policy explicitly opposing prostitution—was damaging to public health. It could severely undermine efforts to prevent the spread of HIV worldwide by impeding organizations that work with key populations, and could intensify stigma and fear among sex workers, driving them further away from HIV education and prevention services.

Everyone at Pathfinder also agreed that the pledge violated free speech. While the government can dictate what can be done with its money, the pledge went far beyond that. It forced groups like Pathfinder to adopt an organization-wide policy, thereby restricting how they spend their own private funds to do HIV work.

All of this weighed heavily on Pathfinder staff and its board of directors. Yet, they had to ask—Is this our fight?

A Risk Worth Taking

During their meeting, the board spoke of the risk. If Pathfinder mounted a legal challenge, could it hurt the organization’s chances for federal funding, not just within PEPFAR (the President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief), but beyond?

When they discussed how the restriction violated the First Amendment, Andrew Frey, a board member who specializes in Supreme Court litigation, rightly pointed out, “The Constitution is violated in some way or another every single day. We must decide if this particular constitutional violation is important enough to Pathfinder’s beliefs and concerns that it stands out from others, meriting action on our part. And if we do join the suit, we should do so with wholehearted commitment.”

The rest of the board agreed, and then added something critical. They noted the common thread between the board and Pathfinders everywhere—they are all compelled to support the world’s most underserved women. So in the final moments of the meeting, the board asked themselves, “Who is more underserved than a female sex worker in a developing country?”

Daniel Pellegrom, Pathfinder’s President and CEO from 1985 to 2011, remembers that question. “I also recall the pause—silence, really—that followed. Finally, someone said, ‘I think we are ready for a vote.’  The measure was moved, seconded, and passed. Pathfinder became co-plaintiff with AOSI (Alliance for Open Society International, Inc.) in a lawsuit against the US Government. There was not one opposing vote on the Pathfinder board.”

Courage is Communicable

“Without Pathfinder, the suit might have gone nowhere,” said Pellegrom. “No other organizations in our field seemed ready to seriously consider joining AOSI; the risk for them evidently outweighed the advantages. But AOSI needed help to meet the test of ‘standing’ in court. Since much of our work is supported by USAID, and we implement HIV and AIDS programs that target sex workers, Pathfinder was able to demonstrate how the pledge would limit our successful strategies in the fight against HIV and AIDS. Once Pathfinder took the plunge, more than 200 other organizations (under the umbrella of InterAction and Global Health Council) chose to align themselves with the case to take a stand.”

The case progressed with one court after another affirming Pathfinder’s stance. The US District Court for the Southern District of New York twice ruled that the pledge violated the First Amendment. In June 2006, the court issued a preliminary injunction, prohibiting USAID and the Department of Health and Human Services from enforcing the pledge against Pathfinder and AOSI. Two years later, the injunction was expanded to include the US-based members of the Global Health Council and InterAction, upon their becoming official co-plaintiffs in the suit.

In 2010, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the District Court’s decision that the pledge could not withstand heightened First Amendment scrutiny. Pathfinder was relieved, but continued its advocacy, believing the biggest test had yet to come.

Finally in April of 2013, more than seven years after Pathfinder’s board of directors took their vote, the Supreme Court of the United States heard the US Government’s appeal of Pathfinder’s lawsuit. In June, the court issued its important decision.

Victory

"This victory will enable us to continue to support the most underserved populations, treating them with the human dignity we all deserve and to do so without compromising any of our principles." -Purnima ManeThe US Supreme Court ruled 6-2 in Agency for International Development v. Alliance for Open Society International, Inc., et al., holding that the anti-prostitution pledge violates the First Amendment and cannot be sustained. In his majority opinion, Chief Justice John Roberts wrote that while Congress may attach conditions to federal funding that specify the activities Congress wishes to subsidize and require federal funds be used only for those purposes, a funding condition is impermissible if it intrudes on private speech outside the contours of the government program. The decision was a strong and resounding message in favor of Pathfinder and fellow co-plaintiffs, AOSI, Inc., InterAction, and Global Health Council, igniting celebrations among Pathfinder staff around the world.

Pathfinder’s current President and CEO, Purnima Mane, believes the victory speaks to the kind of organization Pathfinder is and always will be. “This victory will enable us to continue to support the most underserved populations, treating them with the human dignity we all deserve and to do so without compromising any of our principles. The onus is now upon us to do an even better job of getting services to all those who need them the most and are often denied access, and on doing so with greater impact and even better quality.”

And in India, where Pathfinder implements a successful project to fight HIV by empowering female sex workers, the verdict is a sign of things to come. “To be honest, I do not think many organizations in the US would have the stomach to do what we did!” said Darshana Vyas, Director of the Mukta project. “Our conviction and hard work all these years certainly paid off. This ruling is going to help marginalized and stigmatized populations we serve all over the world.”

Focus Area: Advocacy

Jonathan J. Rucks

Jonathan J. Rucks is Pathfinder International's Director of Advocacy.

Leave a Comment

* Change

Comments

The Supreme Court does have a lot of cases and the case continues to grow. You should already be looking for solutions to get there. Best Electrolysis Salon Kent
EvelineSchroeder July 30, 2014
Wow, superb blog format! How long have you been running a blog for? you make blogging glance easy. check this post
Name July 29, 2014
Many thanks for the exciting blog posting! Simply put your blog post to my favorite blog list and will look forward for additional updates. Simply wanted to write down a word in order to say thanks to you for those wonderful tips. bulk sms reseller
bulksmsbase.com July 28, 2014
Place in Worldwide Download Free Software, Download Software and Games Full Version, Download IDM Full Crack, Free Download Free software
adm July 27, 2014
ApniFile WORLD Best Site for Solve your Computer Problems,Free Pc Games Free Download, Software,crack patch & keygen for All Software and Games Free, Free Download Pc Games
Skype ID : Bad.boy0007 July 27, 2014
God Of War 3 PC Game Full Version. God OF War 3 is a wonderful PC game full version highly compressed. The GOD of war 3 PC game ripped download TusFiles Link %100 working Download now .God of war PC games. God of war 3 download God Of WAR PC GAME 3 download highly compressed.God of war 3 PC game download complete Full and Final version. God of war 3 mediafire download and Tusfiles. God of War PC game original game torrent download. Utorrent god of war 3 PC game download. 3 gow3 download.Frepczone.com God Of War 3 PC
admin July 27, 2014
Watch free online movies for free streaming better than crackle movies online and HD movie4k at ugetmovie, you can watch horror, comedy, action Bollywood watch movies online
Badboy July 27, 2014
I am very happy to read this article .. thanks for giving us go through info.Fantastic nice. I appreciate this post. venus factor reviews
venus factor reviews July 27, 2014
I would like to thank you for your nicely written post, its informative and your writing style encouraged me to read payday loans
jack89 July 26, 2014
hello friends you can get free clash of clans game codes and download gold through this site...clash of clans hack
babu July 26, 2014
"This victory will enable us to continue to support the most underserved populations, treating them with the human dignity we all deserve and to do so without compromising any of our principles." -Purnima Mane. This is a good victory..bulk sms in nigeria
Matico July 25, 2014
Since the time the eBook was released in mid-September, it's been downloaded more than 1,000 times. sexy corsets
sexy corsets July 24, 2014
I must spend a while finding out more or understanding more. Thank you for fantastic information I used to be searching for this info for my mission. bt openreach contact number
jack89 July 23, 2014
Michael Fiore is extremely successful at helping couples reunite after breakups, and he does it using a method few relationship experts dare touch…that of text messaging. I want to take you inside Mike’s system and share with you some of the reasons why using your cell phone to tap out a few simple text messages can have a dramatic impact on your relationship.http://ebookreviews.ning.com/pdf/
asadalikhatri July 23, 2014
I read whole the post and get so much information. Thanks for this info. Harlem Place
Adward Maya July 22, 2014
This site is a leading resource for information about the Anna Wilson and Mirabelle Summers Conversation Chemistry PDF book and attraction system that teaches you how to use the art of conversation to build attraction, create sexual tension, and make yourself more desirable in any dating interaction.conversation chemistry by mirabelle summers testimonials
asadalikhatri July 21, 2014
The easy to implement concepts and techniques (centered around the fat burning hormone leptin) taught in the course are specifically designed for women. Unlike other weight loss programs that focus solely on getting you "super thin", the Venus Factor system.reviews of venus factor weight loss
asadalikhatri July 20, 2014
In our early tests of lacoste pas cher , we’re seeing 20-30% user response rates (significantly higher than traditional surveys), coming through in near real time. This enables brands to turn the results into immediate action: brands that are using Survey Lift have seen an 82% lift in soldes lacoste ad recall, along with a 64% lift in brand awareness. For example MasterCard was able to double brand recall for one of their holiday campaigns based on insights gleaned from surveys. Based on lacoste paris this early promising feedback, we’ll be rolling these surveys out more broadly, for more types of campaigns, in coming months.
supra pas cher July 19, 2014
Scroll to top