Why We Went All the Way to the Supreme Court

“To the thousands of sex workers we serve, this ruling could absolutely be hope for a better life!” —Darshana Vyas, Director of the Mukta project, Pathfinder International

"I have always been proud of Pathfinder's courage—its willingness to go where others fear to go, which is a legacy from our founders." —Cynthia Fields, Chairperson of the Board of Directors, Pathfinder International

“It is a historic victory for us, and also vindication of our stand that promoting safer sexual practices among sex workers for prevention of HIV did not mean promoting prostitution.” —Darshana Vyas, Director of the Mukta project, Pathfinder International

"The Brazilian Network of Sex Workers shared that 'the decision shows the importance of the judiciary in guaranteeing rights violated by the executive and other bodies.'” —Carlos Laudari, Pathfinder's Senior Technical Advisor, HIV Prevention

“We stay ready to continue our partnership with the US government and all others who work with us to deliver quality, high impact programs that reach those most at need and often denied access.” —Purnima Mane, President and CEO

“If we proceed with this lawsuit, we have to be all in.”

On the morning of November 29, 2005, Pathfinder International’s board of directors had to make a monumental decision of whether or not to sue the organization’s largest funder—the US Government.

Everyone at Pathfinder agreed that the “Anti-Prostitution Pledge”—a 2003 law requiring all groups receiving US Government funds for international HIV and AIDS work have a policy explicitly opposing prostitution—was damaging to public health. It could severely undermine efforts to prevent the spread of HIV worldwide by impeding organizations that work with key populations, and could intensify stigma and fear among sex workers, driving them further away from HIV education and prevention services.

Everyone at Pathfinder also agreed that the pledge violated free speech. While the government can dictate what can be done with its money, the pledge went far beyond that. It forced groups like Pathfinder to adopt an organization-wide policy, thereby restricting how they spend their own private funds to do HIV work.

All of this weighed heavily on Pathfinder staff and its board of directors. Yet, they had to ask—Is this our fight?

A Risk Worth Taking

During their meeting, the board spoke of the risk. If Pathfinder mounted a legal challenge, could it hurt the organization’s chances for federal funding, not just within PEPFAR (the President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief), but beyond?

When they discussed how the restriction violated the First Amendment, Andrew Frey, a board member who specializes in Supreme Court litigation, rightly pointed out, “The Constitution is violated in some way or another every single day. We must decide if this particular constitutional violation is important enough to Pathfinder’s beliefs and concerns that it stands out from others, meriting action on our part. And if we do join the suit, we should do so with wholehearted commitment.”

The rest of the board agreed, and then added something critical. They noted the common thread between the board and Pathfinders everywhere—they are all compelled to support the world’s most underserved women. So in the final moments of the meeting, the board asked themselves, “Who is more underserved than a female sex worker in a developing country?”

Daniel Pellegrom, Pathfinder’s President and CEO from 1985 to 2011, remembers that question. “I also recall the pause—silence, really—that followed. Finally, someone said, ‘I think we are ready for a vote.’  The measure was moved, seconded, and passed. Pathfinder became co-plaintiff with AOSI (Alliance for Open Society International, Inc.) in a lawsuit against the US Government. There was not one opposing vote on the Pathfinder board.”

Courage is Communicable

“Without Pathfinder, the suit might have gone nowhere,” said Pellegrom. “No other organizations in our field seemed ready to seriously consider joining AOSI; the risk for them evidently outweighed the advantages. But AOSI needed help to meet the test of ‘standing’ in court. Since much of our work is supported by USAID, and we implement HIV and AIDS programs that target sex workers, Pathfinder was able to demonstrate how the pledge would limit our successful strategies in the fight against HIV and AIDS. Once Pathfinder took the plunge, more than 200 other organizations (under the umbrella of InterAction and Global Health Council) chose to align themselves with the case to take a stand.”

The case progressed with one court after another affirming Pathfinder’s stance. The US District Court for the Southern District of New York twice ruled that the pledge violated the First Amendment. In June 2006, the court issued a preliminary injunction, prohibiting USAID and the Department of Health and Human Services from enforcing the pledge against Pathfinder and AOSI. Two years later, the injunction was expanded to include the US-based members of the Global Health Council and InterAction, upon their becoming official co-plaintiffs in the suit.

In 2010, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals upheld the District Court’s decision that the pledge could not withstand heightened First Amendment scrutiny. Pathfinder was relieved, but continued its advocacy, believing the biggest test had yet to come.

Finally in April of 2013, more than seven years after Pathfinder’s board of directors took their vote, the Supreme Court of the United States heard the US Government’s appeal of Pathfinder’s lawsuit. In June, the court issued its important decision.

Victory

"This victory will enable us to continue to support the most underserved populations, treating them with the human dignity we all deserve and to do so without compromising any of our principles." -Purnima ManeThe US Supreme Court ruled 6-2 in Agency for International Development v. Alliance for Open Society International, Inc., et al., holding that the anti-prostitution pledge violates the First Amendment and cannot be sustained. In his majority opinion, Chief Justice John Roberts wrote that while Congress may attach conditions to federal funding that specify the activities Congress wishes to subsidize and require federal funds be used only for those purposes, a funding condition is impermissible if it intrudes on private speech outside the contours of the government program. The decision was a strong and resounding message in favor of Pathfinder and fellow co-plaintiffs, AOSI, Inc., InterAction, and Global Health Council, igniting celebrations among Pathfinder staff around the world.

Pathfinder’s current President and CEO, Purnima Mane, believes the victory speaks to the kind of organization Pathfinder is and always will be. “This victory will enable us to continue to support the most underserved populations, treating them with the human dignity we all deserve and to do so without compromising any of our principles. The onus is now upon us to do an even better job of getting services to all those who need them the most and are often denied access, and on doing so with greater impact and even better quality.”

And in India, where Pathfinder implements a successful project to fight HIV by empowering female sex workers, the verdict is a sign of things to come. “To be honest, I do not think many organizations in the US would have the stomach to do what we did!” said Darshana Vyas, Director of the Mukta project. “Our conviction and hard work all these years certainly paid off. This ruling is going to help marginalized and stigmatized populations we serve all over the world.”

Focus Area: Advocacy

Jonathan J. Rucks

Jonathan J. Rucks is Pathfinder International's Director of Advocacy.

Leave a Comment

* Change

Comments

Prada Outlet Online, http://www.shopbestgoods.com/
Coach Outlet, http://www.bestcustomsonline.com/
Nike Air Max, http://www.nike-jordanshoes.com/
Polo Ralph Lauren Oultet, http://www.polo-tshirts.com/
cheap beats by dre, http://www.beatsbydreoutlet.net/
Michael Kors Bags Outlet, http://www.michaelkorsus.com/
North Face Outlet Online, http://www.northsclearance.com/
Polo Outlet Online, http://www.ralph-laurensale.com/
Gucci Outlet Online, http://www.gucci-shoesuk2014.com/
Louis Vuitton Outlet Online, http://www.louisvuittonas.com
Michael Kors Black Friday, http://www.michael-korsusa.com/
Polo Outlet Store Online, http://www.polo-outlets.com/
Hermes Black Friday, http://www.hermes-outletonline.com/
Polo Outlet, http://www.ralphslauren.co.uk/
Marc Jacobs Black Friday, http://www.marcjacobsonsale.com/
MCM Bags Outlet, http://www.mcmworldwides.com/
Cheap Longchamp Bags, http://www.salongchamppairs.com/
Canada Goose Sale, http://www.canada-gooser.com/
Burberry Factory Outlet, http://www.burberryoutlet2014.com/
Michael Kors Cyber Monday, http://www.michaelkors.so/
Cheap Oakley Sunglaases, http://www.oakley-sunglassoutlet.com/
North Face Outlet, http://www.north-faceoutlets.net/
Moncler Jackets Outlet Online, http://www.moncler-clearance.com/
Woolrich Jackets Black Friday, http://www.woolrich-clearance.com/
Barbour Jackets Black Friday, http://www.barbour-jacketsoutlet.com/
Moncler Jackets Black Friday, http://www.moncler-jacketsoutletonline.com/
Monster Beats Black Friday, http://www.monsterbeatsbydres.net/
Louis Vuitton Black Friday, http://www.louis-vuittonblackfriday.com/
Louis Vuitton Shoes Factory, http://www.lv-guccishoesfactory.com/
Cheap Clothes Sale, http://www.cheapdiscountoutlet.com/
Coach Outlet Online, http://coachoutlet.iwopop.com/
Coach Factory Store, http://www.coachsfactoryoutlet.com/
Coach Black Friday 2014, http://www.coach-blackfriday2014.com/
Coach Cyber Monday, http://www.coach-storeoutletonline.com/
Coach Black Friday, http://www.coach-factorysoutletonline.com/
Shop Coach Factory, http://www.coachccoachoutlet.com/
Coach Bags Factory, http://www.coach-factories.net/
Cheap Coach Purses, http://www.coach-pursesoutletonline.com/
Coach Outlet Online, http://www.coach-outletsusa.com/
Coach Outlet USA, http://www.zxcoachoutlet.com/
Coach Factory Outlet Online, http://www.mischristmas.com/
Black Friday, http://www.misblackfriday.com/
Coach Purses Store Online, http://www.newoutletonlinemall.com/
Ralph Lauren Polo, http://www.ralphlaurenepolo.com/
Ralph Lauren Black Friday
Coach Outlet Online Michael Kors Outlet, http://michaelkorsoutlet.mischristmas.com/
MCM Backpack Outlet, http://mcmbackpack.mischristmas.com/
Monster Beats Outlet, http://monsterbeats.mischristmas.com/
North Face Outlet, http://northfaceoutlet.mischristmas.com/
MK Black Friday, http://mk.misblackfriday.com/
Coach Outlet Black Friday, http://coachoutlet.misblackfriday.com/
Coach Factory Black Friday, http://coachfactory.misblackfriday.com/
Ugg Australia Black Friday, http://uggaustralia.misblackfriday.com/
Coach Purses Black Friday, http://coachpurses.misblackfriday.com/
Coach Outlet USA, http://coachusa.misblackfriday.com/
Coach Black Friday, http://coach.misblackfriday.com/
Michael Kors Outlet Online, http://michaelkorss.misblackfriday.com/
Michael Kors Black Friday, http://michaelkors.misblackfriday.com/
Air Max Black Friday, http://airmax.misblackfriday.com/
Michael Kors Factory, http://michael-kors.misblackfriday.com/ Coach Outlet Black Friday, http://www.shopbestgoods.com/
Louis Vuitton Black Friday
Hermes Black Friday
Prada Cyber Monday
ChanelBlack Friday
Gucci Black Friday
Burberry Cyber Monday
Celine Cyber Monday
Balenciaga Cyber Monday
Christian Dior Black Friday
Chloe Black Friday
Bvlgari Black Friday
Bally Cyber Monday
Coach Cyber Monday 2014
Michael Kors Black Friday
MCM Backpack Black Friday
Fendi Black Friday
mulberry Cyber Monday
Marc Jacobs Cyber Monday
Miu Miu Black Friday
Ysl Black Friday
Tory Burch Black Friday
Givenchy Black Friday
Ferragamo Black Friday
Lancel Black Friday
Loewe Black Friday
Tods Black Friday
Paul Smith Black Friday
D&G Black Friday
Alexander Wang Black Friday
Bottega Veneta Black Friday

polo October 1, 2014
We must decide if this particular constitutional violation is important enough to Pathfinder’s beliefs and concerns that it stands out from others, meriting action on our part. You did work very well. http://safetymatsuk.co.uk/safety-flooring/garden-safety-mats.html
Morgan October 1, 2014
very good effort . I really appreciate and like it .Thanks and keep it up. soccer scrimmage vests
Thomas Peter September 30, 2014
Simply put your blog post to my favorite blog list and will look forward for additional updates. Simply wanted to write down a word in order to say thanks seo in barcelona
jack89 September 30, 2014
I am always searching online for articles that can help me. There is obviously a lot to know about this. I think you made some good points in Features also. Keep working, great job Medical Negligence Solicitor
Medical Negligence Solicitor September 30, 2014
This is appreciable post. You did great job. It is very informative for us and thanks for shearing. dvd jackets for sale
Peter September 30, 2014
Where else could anybody get that type of info in such an ideal way of writing? compare auto insurance
franklin7 September 29, 2014
Well interesting discussion glad that I came across such informative post. Keep up the good work friend. Glad to be part of your net community. Medical Negligence Solicitors
Medical Negligence Solicitors September 29, 2014
I wish more authors of this type of content would take the time you did to research and write so well. I am very impressed with your vision and insight. home insurance quotes online comparison
ALI September 28, 2014
This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing websites that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free. No Win No Fee Claims
No Win No Fee Claims September 28, 2014
mont blanc legend louis vuitton outlet store gucci shoes coach outlet cheap nfljerseys ray ban sunglasses true religion jeans michael kors outlet store gucci bags oakley sunglasses wholesale prada handbags ray bans true religion jeans men michael kors outlet online gucci outlet kate spade purses coach factory prada shoes workout routines celine paris toms shoes sale true religion outlet hair dryer red bottom shoes burberry bags cheap toms Michael Kors Outlet Online Sale abercrombie cheap nfl jerseys ray bans fendi purses Michael Kors Outlet Online Sale louis vuitton purses fitflop sale ab workouts true religion outlet store christian louboutin sneakers ralph lauren gucci outlet store chanel outlet kate spade outlet store louis vuitton handbags michael kors outlet online the north face sale hermes outlet trye religion outlet store ray ban outlet stores ray ban sunglasses used louis vuitton fitflop outlet coach factory outlet true religion jeans outlet true religion jeans louboutin michael kors handbags toms shoes outlet christian louboutin ray ban juicy couture outlet fitflops online prda outlet kate spade handbags true religion jeans outlet coach factory online true religion jeans outlet burberry outlet juicy couture kate spade outlet kate spade outlet mont blanc mountain oakley suglasses cheap louis vuitton purses michael kors backpack toms shoes true religion outlet fitflop footwear abercrombie fitch louis vuitton shoes coach factory outlet oakley glasses tory burch outlet online cheap uggs louis vuitton usa christian louboutin outlet burberry scarf fitflop shoes bottega veneta bags the north face outlet michael kors outlet louis vuitton belt workout plans jordan shoes bottega veneta outlet marc jacobs handbags coach outlet celine bag price michael kors outlet online christian louboutin shoes ralph lauren outlet Michael Kors Outlet Online kate spade louis vuitton bags jordan 11 discount ray ban sunglasses p90x workout schedule polo ralph lauren Coach Factory Store louis vuitton ugg boots Coach Factory jordan sneakers louis vuitton ray ban aviators louis vuitton uk fendi outlet michael kors outlet true religion jeans louis vuitton purses cheap jerseys oakley sunglasses wholesale nfl jerseys nfl jerseys louis vuitton louis vuitton outlet store cheap oakleys hollister promo code celine outlet fitflop footwear chi flat iron hollister kids the north face cheap ray ban sunglasses louis vuitton purses ugg sale coach factory outlet online coach outlet online kate spade handbags louis vuitton sunglasses louboutin shoes Michael Kors Handbags celine luggage tote prada bags ralph lauren home toms shoes ray ban outlet marc by marc jacobs uggs australia bottega veneta handbags louis vuitton outlet jordan shoes red shoes fitflop sandals michael kors outlet hermes bracelet louis vuitton outlet coach factory online marc jacobs outlet trye religion outlet fitflops clearance louis vuitton handbags louis vuitton outlet cheap jerseys from china ray ban sunglasses outlet louis vuitton outlet fitflops michael kors bags tory burch flats crossfit workouts Coach Outlet louis vuitton neverfull tory burch shoes true religion toms outlet hair straightener abercrombie and fitch ray ban wayfarer fitflop outlet cheap louis vuitton michael kors handbags cheap true religion jeans jordan for women louis vuitton handbags ray ban sunglasses toms promo code north face jackets louis vuitton outlet mont blanc fountain pens mont blanc fountain pen louis vuitton wallet kate spade outlet online polo outlet oakley outlet cheap jordan for sale nfl jerseys wholesale marc jacobs fitflop sandals outlet Michael Kor Outlet louis vuitton handbags fendi hermes belt gucci handbags kate spade factory outlet jordan retro juicy couture perfume coach factory fitflop outlet chanel bags nfl football jerseys hollister clothing louis vuitton purses red bottoms toms outlet burberry handbags jordan retro coach outlet store online coach factory online jordans for sale chanel handbags louis vuitton purses mont blanc legend joe abercrombie air jordan shoes christian louboutin outlet louis vuitton speedy cheap jordans louis vuitton handbags louis vuitton christian louboutin shoes fendi handbags tory burch handbags cheap jordans louis vuitton outlet Michael Kors Outlet designer handbags louis vuitton bags Michael Kors Handbags louis vuitton handbags mont blanc pens insanity workout viva la juicy coach factory outlet online coach factory outlet coach factory outlet coach outlet bottega veneta louis vuitton bags michael kors bags mont blanc pen hollister outlet ray ban sunglasses wholesale chi hair straightener trye religion outlet ray ban outlet www.louisvuitton.com hermes birkin bottega veneta outlet online toms sale hollister co fitflops clearance christian louboutin cheap jordans coach outlet store online mont blanc pens cheap ray bans chanel online shop Michael Kors Outlet Online chi straightener michael kors purses ugg outlet tory burch outlet louis vuitton speedy coach factory louis vuitton belts louis vuitton officail website cheap oakley sunglasses fitflop shoes louis vuitton outlet stores cheap jerseys ugg boots sale oakley outlet kate spade fendi bags louis vuitton bags hermes delivery red heels christian louboutin sale toms wedges oakley sunglasses jordan 13 louisvuitton coach outlet store online louis vuitton true religion ray ban glasses true religion jeans jordan shoes mont blanc pen louis vuitton wallet abercrombie and kent Coach Factory Online Coach Factory Outlet louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton handbags coach factory online football jersey louis vuitton outlet true religion sale celine handbags coach outlet louis vuitton outlet louis vuitton outlet stores oakley sunglasses michael kors handbags louis vuitton backpack
Name September 27, 2014
I was very pleased to find this site.I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post. venus factor
venus factor September 27, 2014
Superbly written article, if only all bloggers offered the same content as you, the internet would be a far better place.. Vbulletin
alix September 27, 2014
Maybe it is not too ambitious to hope—if we can fully rise to the occasion—that we might be able to co-create a multi-media work of art that tenderly witnesses this middle point that humanity finds itself at right now No Win No Fee Claims
No Win No Fee Claims September 27, 2014
Great info! I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have. Rebel Mouse
alix September 27, 2014
Other popular festivals and events in Fuerteventura include the Corpus Christi festivities and Fuerteventura Musical technology Festival every June, your International Spruce Festival throughout July, as well as Fuerteventura's International Kite Festival in November - which usually lasts for three days and appeals to large crowds of people. I've thought we would merge both of these days simply because our stop by at Fuerteventura was your shortest of our stops. When N . stay on the East coast, Hole Beach, an essay the breeze swings NE there will be a light onshore piece of cake at The flag Beach but will be peaceful in Cotillo. Hole during the the summer months are flatter water, ok it's not a lagoon but its not huge swell. Rocks at the flag are visable at low wave but the exit and entry suggests the water are clearly signifies. As long as you utilize common sense and stick to these areas you'll have no difficulties. One quick thing about the particular lagoon in cotillo, it's illegal to be able to kite there. Look for sharks and the spectacular reef below: if you do this properly it may be the greatest surf of your life. Intense sports, excessive landscape, and very gorgeous temperature: it's obvious that an adventure holiday in order to Fuerteventura won't let down. James is currently writing for , any flights evaluation who compare flights to be able to Fuerteventura and through Spain as well as hundreds of additional airports worldwide. If water sports are your thing, you'll never go far wrong with Fuerteventura, hi. The town is located right at the heart with the Michael Hoffer Fuerteventura island. At the centre there are also sunbeds along with a beach bar in the palm garden - a great place to watch the experience from or to sit and relax. Sotavento is a great spot for kitersurfers. The beach literally expands for mls which means almost always there is plenty of room for starting and getting and there is constantly space about the water. Rene Elgi A single, the kitesurfing centre through the Playa Paraiso apartments , has a selection of prime brand Cabrinha kites for school and hire equipment. Sotavento is an excellent spot for almost all levels of kiteboarders. Among the classic occasions in Fuerteventura will be the carnival of Puerto del Rosario, ideal for starting the year with tempo; in summer season, there is this type of variety of concerts, parties and shows that it must be difficult to select among all ones.
Austin September 26, 2014
Yes i am always with your post because i like this blog and it is very useful for me and thanks for this. round stickers
Peter September 26, 2014
This is really a nice and informative, containing all information and also has a great impact on the new technology. Thanks for sharing it. 3 part carbonless forms
jordan September 26, 2014
I alone do would admire to allowance a monster as a after-effects of the account esteem Dentist Boca raton
jack89 September 26, 2014
Scroll to top